Where There’s Craft There’s Hope

The first Cog Blog post appeared in 2013. Although it was tempting to speak of gears, and the interconnected nature of things, in reality COG was an acronym for Cynical Old Git.

There was, indeed there still is, plenty to be cynical about. The behaviours of our largest agencies; the subsequent erosion of trust between agency and client; the fraud that infects much online advertising; the collapse of the collegiate approach to audience measurement; the failure to address structural flaws by hiding behind some ill-defined definition of value; the deprioritising of clients’ needs in favour of making a quick buck. And so on.

I am an optimist. In my simple view of the ad world an agency succeeds via the success it brings its clients. Do good work that works, talk about it, win more clients, make more money.

It isn’t: create complexity, confuse clients, then charge for navigating a world you’ve helped make more complex.

I grew up in agencies where the assets went up and down in the lift. The agency’s assets were its people; good people created client success; bad people wasted money.

It was a people business. It still is; machines, algorithms, AI and optimisers can only take you so far. No machine will think of building something around confusing a small relative of the mongoose with the word for a structure designed for buyers to meet sellers.

Yet a wonderful ad agency, VCCP, and a brave client, Compare the Market, made history.

When something or somebody provides a sliver of hope to an industry under threat of automation we should all give thanks.

Such slivers are rare in the media business. We’ve become used to chasing audiences at lower and lower cost; to looking the other way when children self-harm as a result of exposure to social media; to shrugging off online fakery and fraud as ‘the cost of doing business’.

We’ve replaced fear-of-missing-out with fear-of-being-found-out.

We’ve forgotten the soft skills, the ability to think critically, to include morals along with numbers.

Our modus operandi makes it a short step to replace people with machines.

We need to celebrate craft skills. To balance machines and data with interpretation and understanding. We need to use the machines, not the other way around.

Last week a sliver appeared. Two planners from the perfectly named Craft Media, Hadyn Millar and Theo Rubins put on an event for their fellow planners from throughout the industry. The topic was the absurdity that advertising within online news is somehow dangerous for brands. They invited ‘Planners who give a shit’ and teamed up with The News Alliance, a cross-industry initiative that champions news environments to advertisers.

The event attracted around 50 to a pub in Soho, to hear speakers including Pippa Glucklich, Starcom’s Lin-Sze Teh, OMD’s Annabel Robson, Jamie Credland from World Media Group, Sarah Jones from Sky and Alex Czapski from T&P.

The two panels spoke of morals, the need for journalists in an era of fake news, the benefits of speaking out and not just accepting the numbers. The commercial benefit of doing the right thing.

This isn’t easy – some of us have stories and scars from similar debates from way back when. At the end of the day all any agency can do is recommend; the client decides.

But recommendations are really important. Clients hire agencies because they want an objective voice, they want to be challenged. Otherwise, why hire agencies at all? Just give the money to Mark Zuckerberg and crack on.

Initiatives like Hadyn’s and Theo’s complement training. I don’t know how much time is spent on industry courses discussing the need for independent thinking. I guess, given who runs the courses, not enough.

We should be equipping today’s young planners with the arguments, the confidence to speak up for the merits of a diverse media ecosystem. A healthy society deserves a varied diet of domestically produced light entertainment, drama, documentaries, sport. And news.

Hence the Advertising: Who Cares? quality media initiative, which argues that every pound spent with the giant platforms is another domestic job gone in casting, in acting, in production, in journalism.

Very clearly the platforms are important and effective advertising vehicles. But when 66% of UK ad revenue goes to three companies, we’re out of balance, we need a course correction.

That’s why Theo, Hadyn and their initiative, The News Alliance, and Advertising: Who Cares? are all important.

It’s encouraging that they did it; it’s even more encouraging that people came along.

Now it becomes harder. Following up, delivering to the principles, keeping on keeping on. Making stuff happen beyond making people feel good.

But that’s not for today; today they should feel proud of themselves. I am proud to have been there.

|
|
|
|

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *